The Huddle is a Gold Mine. (Response to Issue No. 8, "Catching")

Posted August 19th, 2008 by Mackey and filed in Offense, catching, throwing
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet. Click to Rate!)
Loading ... Loading ...

Catching. Such an essential, fundamental component of ultimate, non? Jesus Christ, just think–250 thousand hits. Already! I hit 2,500 last month and thought I was doing well.

I’ve touched upon a lot of the same stuff the huddle authors touch upon already with my catching talk in this blog–the importance of attacking the disc cannot be overstated at high levels, and using your body is an underappreciated but equally important component of making uncontested grabs. Read all of the articles, and note the frequency with which some of the information is repeated–continuity of an idea is a pretty good predictor for its utility.

I’d like to draw attention to a couple gems that really stood out for me, courtesy of Nancy Sun and Gwen Ambler.

Taking a direction completely different from her co-writers, Nancy talks about receiving the pull–but when she talks about catching and throwing at the end, there’s a bit worth pulling outside of the the context of just pull receiving.

First, on catching (emphasis mine):

3. Execution. I want to pancake the pull at chest height and close to my body. I focus on keeping my hands at 90 degree angles to each other (as opposed to parallel) to eliminate misalignment and the chance that the disc might flip out of my hands.

Brilliant. Just pick up a disc and try this at home. I could NOT flub a clap catch with my hands oriented at 90 degrees. Whenever you teach somebody how to clap catch from now on, make sure you specify the importance angle of the hands–this is a very simple hangup that somebody who fancies herself uncoordinated will get caught on when first learning to play.

Second, on the catch-throw turnaround:

Getting your feet into a balanced throwing position should be done simultaneous to catching. Tenths of a second can be the difference between hitting the swing or having the mark come on to prevent you from hitting the swing…As a right-handed thrower, I mostly pancake with my right hand on top so that sliding into a backhand grip is very quick. Coming out of the pancake, right-hand on top is also the most natural and secure motion for me to enter into my forehand grip.

If you haven’t already, think about your hands’ positioning when you catch with regards to being able to throw right afterwards. I’ve already mused on this here (it’s really nice to see some of my thoughts validated by elite ultimate players), so give that a look for a bit more exposition on that topic if you want. For the record, I am now more comfortable catching right hand on top, but transition pretty quickly to throwing in either orientation.

Also, play around with your footwork and how you set your body up to make a continuation when you receive the disc–if you receive in a balanced position (“balanced” can be in motion towards a throw, too), you’ll be able to execute a throw shortly thereafter under control. Perhaps more specifics on that at a later time.

Gwen also chooses to go in a different direction than her peers–rather than getting into the nitty-gritty of practicing catches, she talks about the mental side to catching and grabbing high/deep passes instead of the under. Read the whole article. And then re-read this part, which resonates a lot with my own catching experience:

You have to anticipate when and where you’re going to reach the disc and already be ready to catch the disc when that time/space arrives.

This does not mean stopping to wait for the disc to get to you. Instead, it often means propelling yourself through the air with your last step so that you have time in the air to concentrate on the watching the disc into your hands. I am always a fan of catching the disc with both feet off the ground, mid-stride whenever possible. This gives your body, hands, and eyes the appropriate time to prepare for the catch.

I almost always catch in stride on a small hop for “good” passes that hover from chest to head height for me to run onto. This prevents any ground-up turbulence (uneven fields, while not ideal, are not uncommon in this sport) from throwing off my catching motion, and generally allows me to continue at the speed I was already cruising at to make the catch. Sometimes you want to accelerate through the catch, but I have yet to find myself caught and D’d up because I catch this way. Perhaps I just need higher-level competition, though. Small, but significant when you consider the sheer volume of catches you make.

Catching Thought: Receiving Under Pressure

Posted August 3rd, 2008 by Mackey and filed in Defense, Offense, catching
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet. Click to Rate!)
Loading ... Loading ...

As I alluded to earlier, relative positioning of the disc (to receiver and defender) is a key consideration not just for the thrower, but for the receiver in situations where the defender is close.

This notion should affect a receiver a few ways:

  1. When setting up one’s cuts, have a mind for where your defender will be when you finally pick a direction to move in. Some of the most frustratingly effective cuts that have been made on me (and which I in turn started making) are set up very simply by moving until the cutter is between the defender and where the cutter expects to receive the disc. In this way, a quick movement gives the cutter the innate advantage of a well-positioned throw without requiring a ton of effort on the part of the thrower.
  2. As soon as the disc goes into the air, a good receiver will not move simply to catch the disc as soon as possible–she will also move, perhaps laterally somewhat in addition to the direction she’s already running in, to position her body behind the the disc’s trajectory. In so doing she will put her body in the way of the disc, making a play more difficult for a defender (picture a football receiver shuffling to catch the ball rather than reaching, allowing them to take a hit while receiving the ball without fumbling).
  3. Along with 2, a good receiver will catch the disc such that a defender cannot make a play through his body without fouling him. This means either attacking the disc as soon as possible in front of him, or, if pancaking the disc (this is seen with some frequency at the elite level), will position his arms such that the lower arm is on the side of his body that the defender is likely to bid from–a good layout D comes from a low angle (high, gazelle-style layouts (hi Watson), while impressive looking, contain a lot of wasted motion in the up-down plane and are less likely to get to the disc as quickly), so using your arm as a buffer (catching with your arm under puts your elbow in the way) in addition to your already well-positioned body makes a clean D nearly impossible.

Feel free to comment if you have additional thoughts here. Certainly the case is such that sometimes you need to lay out for the grab, but that falls under “exceptional” rather than “good,” in my opinion.

Catching Thought: Focus on the spin

Posted July 29th, 2008 by Mackey and filed in Mental Aspects, Offense, catching, focus
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet. Click to Rate!)
Loading ... Loading ...

See the frisbee clearly when you catch it.

This comes inspired by the Inner Game of Tennis, which I just read recently (if you fancy yourself an athlete, this is mandatory reading. If you hope to learn anything from athletics you can apply to the rest of your life, this is mandatory reading). Galwey, after an initial explanation of some fundamentals of tennis play (which is all tied in to performance and performance mindset), suggests simply to focus on the spin of the ball as a means to concentration, getting your mind out of your body’s way.

Have you ever dropped a disc because you were thinking about your next throw or how you were going to spike it or some other facet of the moment not directly related to the catching of the disc? I should amend that to “have you ever dropped a disc because you were thinking,” because all thoughts are a distraction.

It’s a bit tougher to constantly focus on one thing in ultimate–unlike in tennis, in which the ball is a constant object of focus, in ultimate the frisbee is really only your primary concern when it is in the air. With each facet of ultimate, you have to focus on the cues specific to that facet–the hips (interspersed with awareness of the frisbee’s location and the play developing around you) for defense, space and the thrower when cutting–and when you’re receiving and the disc is in the air, you should have little else on your mind beside the spin of the disc.

I don’t mean contemplate the spin of the disc, thinking about the disc’s spin. I mean, simply, noticing how it is spinning and moving in space. Let your body find and attack the frisbee (these are skills you develop with focused practice–perhaps more on that in a later post), and keep your mind out of it by devoting your attention to the disc’s spin.

Give it a try sometime when you’re tossing. Don’t judge based on initial results–you have to learn to trust your body, and your body has to learn that you’re trusting it, which can take a little while–but let it go for 10, 15 minutes and see if you don’t notice a difference, an extra ease to your motion. And then see if you can’t carry that same ease and relaxation into your in-game performance, too.

Catching Thought: Layout Grabs

Posted July 27th, 2008 by Mackey and filed in Defense, Offense, catching
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet. Click to Rate!)
Loading ... Loading ...

This is something I never really thought about until this spring, when I was teaching somebody how to lay out.

How do you grab the disc when you lay out?

As far as I can gather, there are a few standard styles:

1) The two hander. You rim catch with both hands or do something close to it, landing full extension with your arms in front of you. This woman missed in her bid and is apparently screaming in frustration for it), but she’s going for the two hander here.

2) The “lay out clap.” You get horizontal, but clap catch–this often leads to a roll on the landing or a landing on the shoulder. Probably the most dangerous kind of layout catch you can do. This guy isn’t even fully extended, and is in for a world of hurt in about two seconds.

3) One handers. With a few subsets, the gist of what I’m thinking about here:
-Fingers on top–for those high grabs you reach up for
-Fingers on bottom–for those low ones you need to get your hand under

You can see the general body mechanics at work in this picture, despite it being a defensive bid. One arm for the disc, the other to guide the body down to the ground.

I ONLY grab frisbees on a layout one handed, with my fingers underneath. And generally right handed when I can swing it, though I think I’m ok with both. Any of the other styles (save the clap, which I try to avoid but will pull out every so often if necessary), I’m very liable to bonk (with fingers on top) or hurt myself (with both arms extended–I always use one to cushion my fall).

Do you have any preference? What’s standard for you, and why? I’ve decided I prefer one handers because it allows for maximal extension and a braced landing (and I fancy myself consistent enough with the one-handed grab that the two hander is unnecessary). And I prefer fingers underneath because it’s an easier transition to sliding on the ground without having the disc stripped, as I use my forearm for impact absorption on the landing (I’ll do a more extensive post on layout technique sometime later). Think about what works and why. And PRACTICE if you’re unhappy with your skillset! Visualization is a nice tool to practice layouts without the extra wear and tear of throwing yourself on the ground repeatedly, if physical practice is too painful. But it’s through repetition that you’ll find the most success in-game.

Throwing/Catching Thought: Grip Training (Types of Grip)

Posted July 14th, 2008 by Mackey and filed in Fitness, Offense, catching, throwing
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet. Click to Rate!)
Loading ... Loading ...

So, how you grip the disc is important. However, as with just about anything in sports, it is not enough just to know how to do it right. You must possess the requisite athleticism to execute–knowledge alone can only take you so far.

So how do you train your grip to be stronger? I actually don’t do a ton of grip training anymore–I’m at a good baseline level, though I imagine a bit more training would help with my forehand hucking in particular–but when I did do grip training, I considered a few things when I planned my grip workouts:

There are different kinds of grip strength.
Pinch: Between individual fingers and your thumb.
Crush: Between your fingers and your palm (the “standard” grip when you think about grip–think handshake)
Support: Not a gripping motion, but the ability to maintain one’s grip (think holding on to a heavy bag full of groceries by the handle)

It’s my opinion that the first and the last are the most important for ultimate. The former is particularly important for catching (think about it–attacking the disc, you should be using your thumb underneath/on top to go with your other fingers), while the latter comes into play more for throwing and transferring power from your hips to the disc. Crush grip really has little relevance to ultimate, and it is not something you need to emphasize in your training (though you should still include it for completeness’ sake from time to time).

So, how do you train pinch and support grip? By gripping, of course!

The easiest way is simply to find a gripper or a grip machine at your local gym. these lend themselves fairly easily to a variety of gripping motions–really think about using your thumb–when I talk about support grip, it’s essentially support pinch grip. Start with a relatively manageable amount of force/weight, doing sets in the upper end of the rep range (think 20 reps), and work down to doing a few reps with higher weight, for reps and for time held closed. Pinching and then holding (whether you pinch with one, two, three, or four fingers simultaneously with your thumb is your prerogative–I prefer two fingers, with middle and pointer, as I think they are the ones that do the brunt of the catching work) allows you to work both types of grip simultaneously.

Another exercise I’ve done for supporting grip is holding plates. Grab a 5 or 10 lb plate and simply hold it with four fingers flush on top and the thumb on bottom (or vice versa). Hold for time. Lather, rinse, repeat.

Other options for grip training:
-Sand/Rice gripping. I’ve never done this myself, but others have.
-Fingertip pushups. I used to do these with regularity. But consider the range of motion in which you’re training your grip by doing these (see below). If you can get to the point where you can do them just on your thumbs or on three fingers (thumb+pointer/middle), you’re on the right track.

More conventional thought says doing things like farmer’s walks and deadlifts are good ways to train grip, and this is true–but it’s not as specific to ultimate (often training primarily crush grip, and in a range of motion unseen in ultimate). I do think, however, that learning to use the hook grip, with your thumb under your fingers, will emphasize strength of the thumb more and will carry over to your grip in ultimate though (to at least some extent).

Another thing to consider is that grip strength is highly specific to the range trained. I can do grip training for climbing, working on gripping at the outermost edges of my hand’s extension (think a hold several inches thick, so there’s a lot of space between your fingers and thumb), but, despite possessing phenomenal strength on the wall, have little to spare when gripping a disc with very little separation between fingers and thumb.

I couldn’t tell you what the exact range for the specificity of the training effect is, but the more you can work your grip in the range you’ll be using in-game (ie, closer together), the more you’ll find the results carry over to throwing and catching in game. That’s not to say you should avoid training grip at the edges of your range–to the contrary, a balanced program necessitates it–but pick your focus wisely.

Finally, grip strength fatigues easily, and recovers slowly. If you’re some kind of superhuman, perhaps you can train grip every day and continue to see improvement. For me, a good grip workout would actually leave me worse off for at least the day following. Some of my best throwing has come after taking a couple days off from throwing and grip training–my hands can recover fully, enabling more confident, sure throws. Keep this in mind when planning your training. Grip training is, primarily, a secondary focus for workouts, so I usually save it for the end of workouts where I won’t have to worry about a fatigued grip affecting my other lifts.

You’ll be surprised what a big difference this can make, though you might not notice the gradual improvement over time.

Catching Thought: What’s your first instinct?

Posted July 8th, 2008 by Mackey and filed in Offense, catching
Tags:
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet. Click to Rate!)
Loading ... Loading ...

Frisbee is not natural. Man never evolved to throw a flying piece of plastic, and there’s really no analog to it in nature (throwing a rock or a spear to kill prey is a far cry from the mechanics used for most throws in ultimate). The same goes for catching–there are certain spots on the frisbee that make for easy catches (see Zips Tips for more on that–really, just read all of Zips tips) and some that make for easy macs.

What’s natural for you? Do you find your catches (one-handed/rim) often have the disc coming into your hand hard (excluding cold weather, where all throws seem to weigh like a brick on impact)? Do you find the disc spinning a little too much upon contact or bouncing out of your hand with regularity? Do you grab the disc, or wait for it to settle into your hand?

Make a deliberate effort on your catches when tossing. Focus on the spin of the frisbee, and try attacking the disc at various points. Learn through trial and error where the “sweet spots” are, especially for tricky throws like hammers and blades. Reinforce this deliberate effort enough, and eventually your first instinct will be not to flub, but a seamless catch. Not thinking about your hands and how you’ll catch the frisbee, but simply watching the disc into your hands.

It’s absolutely essential, if you want to play at a high level in this sport, to make frisbees as natural to you as any other implement (perhaps even more so). I spent the couple weeks leading up to Regionals my sophomore year (’06) (and during my summer throwing in Japan in ’05) carrying a frisbee with me everywhere, constantly throwing to myself and catching it. Hone your instincts.

Being Quick on the Catch-Throw Turnaround

Posted December 21st, 2007 by Mackey and filed in Offense, catching, throwing
1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (No Ratings Yet. Click to Rate!)
Loading ... Loading ...

One of the things that I feel like is a great strength for me as a player is the ability to quickly move from catching the disc to throwing it again–and not just a swilly upside-down backhand or a rushed toss, but legitimately stepping out and throwing a backhand or a forehand.

It’s a key skill for playing well in flow, I think (more important is your sense of timing and positioning to get the disc in the first place; perhaps more on that some other time). The longer you take to throw after you catch, the less yardage gained on the in cut or the smaller window of opportunity to throw to the deep cut.

So how does one improve turnaround time? In my mind, it’s all about how you catch. I don’t know how commonplace this is amongst all ultimate players, but from some conversations with guys on the team, especially the young guns, it’s often overlooked.

I catch almost exclusively with my left hand. On throws that I two-hand, lobster style with both on the rim, the right hand is usually like a guiding hand on a basketball shot–there to ensure it goes where I want. If the disc naturally spins to a stop into my right hand I’ll simply pull it out with the left hand. On pancake catches my left hand is almost always on top, so I can pull the disc with my left hand so that my right hand, already underneath in proper orientation to grab the disc, can grab the rim ready to throw.

Think about it. What’s the main limiting factor in going from catching to throwing again? If you catch with your throwing hand, you need to take the disc out of the throwing hand and then re-insert it in proper throwing position–or, manage some one-handed maneuver to do the same (which tends to be even slower). But if you catch with your off hand, you’ve already eliminated the “remove disc from throwing hand” step and can simply place the disc in your throwing hand, which should already be ready to go. The other option to improve turnaround is to do the upside-down lobster catch, where both hands are on the rim in the proper throwing orientation already. Those situations are fewer and farther between, though.

With a bit of focused practice catching and working on the transition, (you can do this anytime and anywhere–just throw the disc to yourself and work on really going-to for the catch with your off hand) you can quickly gain comfort with this kind of catching and throwing. I know a lot of guys who aren’t ambi-catchers–they catch with their dominant (throwing) hand only. It’s limiting! Learning little things like this can result in a significantly positive change on field.

It’s to the point for me now where I catch the disc and can immediately go into stepping to make the next throw–between my catching the disc and my being fully extended the disc goes from ‘caught’ to ‘ready to throw,’ and there’s no time lost in transition (the step is the limiting factor). I actually need to work on right-handed catching more now, as my instinct is to always go with the left and I need to re-learn which situations require right hand just (like layouts for a Callahan against one of the best teams in the country).

Page 2 of 212